Who may write what in a QME report
Short version: of the 17 parts of a typical QME report, 6 are clerical and any staff member or tool may produce them, 3 may be prepared by others if you review them and name who did it, and 8 are yours alone. The table below gives the rule for each part and what AI may do there.
Limits: Not legal or billing advice. California rules are quoted as read on 2026-11-19 from dir.ca.gov; verify the current text there before you bill, sign or serve, and ask counsel about your case.
The 3 categories
8 CCR 41(c)(2) has you review the records yourself and has the report summarize them. 8 CCR 41(c)(7) reserves every part that discusses medical issues, research and conclusions to the evaluator. The DWC checklist adds that you should not rely on a summary from another source without checking it against the records. That gives 3 categories:
- Clerical. Staff or software may produce it. You stay responsible for it being right.
- Prepared by others, reviewed by you. You review all of it and name who did it.
- Physician only. You produce it. Software may type your words; it may not supply the reasoning.
The QME report, part by part
Rules read on 2026-11-12 from 8 CCR 41, 8 CCR 35.5, 8 CCR 36, 8 CCR 10682 and the DWC checklist. The "AI may" column, and any row marked "our reading", is our reading, not a ruling.
| # | Report part | Who | Rule | AI may |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Header, caption, parties, claim numbers | Clerical | Our reading | Fill from the referral letter. Check names and ADJ numbers. |
| 2 | Exam date, street address, signing date | Clerical, stated for you | 8 CCR 35.5(b) | Insert from the calendar. You confirm. |
| 3 | Referral questions from each party's letter | Clerical list; you answer them | 8 CCR 35.5(c)(1) | List the questions with the letter dates, so none is missed. |
| 4 | Index of records received, with dates and pages | Clerical | 8 CCR 41(c)(2) list; 10682(b)(4) | Build the index. You check it is complete. |
| 5 | Page count and record declarations | Clerical count; you verify | DWC checklist; 8 CCR 9793(n) | Count pages and flag missing declarations. You verify the total. |
| 6 | Initial outline of the history (intake form, questionnaire) | Others prepare, you review | Our reading | Organize the questionnaire. You review the whole outline and ask follow-up questions. |
| 7 | Record excerpts and chronology with page cites | Others prepare, you review | DWC checklist | Extract dated entries with page numbers. You review every excerpt and still read the records. |
| 8 | Diagnostic studies run by others | Others perform | Our reading | Nothing. |
| 9 | History taken from the worker | Physician only | Our reading | Transcribe your interview notes. |
| 10 | Physical examination | Physician only | Our reading | Transcribe your findings. |
| 11 | Summary of records reviewed | Physician only | 8 CCR 41(c)(2) | Point you to pages. The summary text is yours, written after the read. |
| 12 | Diagnoses | Physician only | 8 CCR 41(c)(7) | Nothing beyond typing. |
| 13 | Discussion of medical issues and research relied on | Physician only | 8 CCR 41(c)(7) | Find candidate articles. You read them and write the discussion. |
| 14 | Causation, apportionment, P&S, impairment rating | Physician only | 8 CCR 41(c)(7) | Find the record entries you asked for. No drafting of the opinion. |
| 15 | Work status, restrictions, future medical care | Physician only | 8 CCR 41(c)(7) | Nothing beyond typing. |
| 16 | Assistance disclosure and declarations | Physician only | 8 CCR 35.5(h); DWC checklist | Hold your template. You adapt it to the file. |
| 17 | Service and proof of service | Clerical; you are responsible | 8 CCR 36; Form 122 or 111 | Prepare the service list and forms. |
The hard line: transcription vs composition
Parts 9 to 15 allow software to type your words. 8 CCR 9795(b) lists typing and transcription as part of what the medical-legal fee pays for. The risk is a tool that does more than type. Modern dictation tools can reorder, expand and "clean up" what you said. Once a tool adds a reason you did not give, or a link between records you did not make, it has started composing.
3 checks keep you on the right side:
- Turn off any "expand", "improve" or "complete" feature for the discussion and conclusion sections.
- Compare the typed text to your dictation for every causation, apportionment and impairment paragraph.
- If a sentence in the conclusions is not something you said or wrote, delete it or rewrite it yourself.
Why the record summary is the part most at risk
The DWC checklist says it in guidance form: do not rely on a summary from another source unless you have checked it against the records it summarizes.
What a tool can safely give you is the map: which pages exist, what is on each, which visits are dated where, which records look missing. You then read with that map and write the summary in your own words. 41(c)(2) requires the report to list and summarize every record reviewed, so a complete index (part 4) and your own summary (part 11) together meet it.
2 evaluators, 1 report
When more than 1 evaluator signs a report, 8 CCR 41(c)(7) requires each to state which parts of the exam they performed and which parts of the discussion and conclusions they drafted. If AI touched the file, say which evaluator ran it and who reviewed its output. A consultation report from another specialty is incorporated by reference and appended, not rewritten.
Applying the table to your template
Open your report template and tag each section with its number from the table. For every section tagged 6, 7 or 8, add a line to your assistance disclosure. For every section tagged 9 to 16, make sure nothing in your workflow sends text into it except your own dictation or typing. Then run the compliance checklist on your next file.
Can my staff summarize records if I review the summary?
Staff may prepare excerpts for your review, and the DWC checklist says not to rely on another source's summary without checking it against the records. 8 CCR 41(c)(2) has you review the records and summarize them in the report, so write the summary yourself.
Is speech-to-text dictation allowed?
Yes. Typing and transcription are clerical, and 8 CCR 9795(b) lists them in what the fee covers. Turn off features that expand or rewrite your words in the opinion sections.
Can AI find literature for my discussion?
It can suggest sources. 8 CCR 41(c)(7) makes the discussion and the research relied on yours, so read every source you cite and confirm it exists and says what you cite it for.